People on their high horses are due for a reality check. Similarly, America is, too. Yesterday, the US of A celebrated their 234th birthday, but what does that even mean? Okay, so on July 4, 1776, the Declaration of Independence was signed...by Americans. Nearly three centuries earlier, in 1492, Columbus sailed the ocean blue, which ultimately led to the untimely (would it ever have been timely?) eviction of the Native Americans who already occupied the land. Now, I was never so great at history, but if you just go up to a random house and kick out the people who live in it, only to claim it as your own, does that actually make it your own? Does that mean you get the right/privilege to make the household decisions and that, when telemarketers call, asking for the head of the household, you can rightfully answer, "Yes, I am [s]he"?While our independence from England itself is a pretty monumental event -- one that deserves recognition and pride -- I'm not so sure the rest of it does. Consider it a reverse Robin Hood, if you will -- rather than stealing from the rich to give to the poor, it seems that the US of A took from the poor (who may, in fact, have been rich with resources), asserted their independence from the rich, and showed no grain of appreciation for the "tramplees" [those who are trampled upon], without whom the US wouldn't have had land to rest their weary egos.
If you're the coach of a youth basketball team and your team cheats, ending up with more points on the scoreboard than their fairly-playing opponents, who actually deserves the praise? Will you continue to celebrate the anniversary of the win-by-cheating annually, with federal holidays, fireworks, and rampant celebrations? Or will you teach your kids a lesson so that history doesn't repeat itself and they can try to make amends for the past and adopt better practices for the future?
What say you, members of the jury? Is the USA founded on principles of cheating and destructive egoism? What exactly are we celebrating, then?
4 comments:
If you are correct that "the USA founded on principles of cheating and destructive egoism" (of course many other countries are too), then what? You don't seem to be saying that we should not celebrate our independence from the colonial oppressor. Rather, we also are colonial oppressors. What now?
I'm certainly not saying the US is the only country like that -- undoubtedly, others are, too..but in considering the age-old debate of what to do about immigrants (and ones who enter the country illegally at that), how can the US get away with a "do as I say, not as I do" attitude?
Governments are big believers in the "that was then, this is now" philosophy ... i.e., they are enormously hypocritical.
"hypocritical"...exactly the word I was thinking
Post a Comment